Kvantitativní přístup v kvalitativní doméně práva: odpověď autorů

Warning

This publication doesn't include Institute of Computer Science. It includes Faculty of Law. Official publication website can be found on muni.cz.

Title in English	Quantitative Approach in a Qualitative Legal Domain: Authors’ Response
Authors	SMEJKALOVÁ Terezie NOVOTNÁ Tereza HARAŠTA Jakub
Year of publication	2023
Type	Article in Periodical
Magazine / Source	Časopis pro pravní vědu a praxi
MU Faculty or unit	Faculty of Law
Citation
web	Open Access článku
Doi	http://dx.doi.org/10.5817/CPVP2023-2-11
Keywords	Citation Analysis; Optimal Relevance; Maximalism in Judicial Decision-making; Stare Decisis
Description	This text is a response to the contributions of Ondřej Kadlec, Jaroslav Benak, Lukáš Králík and Arkady Alexandrov and Pavel Ondřejek responding to the book Citační analýza judikatury [Citation Analysis of Case Law]. Their reactions and suggestions are discussed across four categories: the obligation to follow case law and stare decisis, the strengths and weaknesses of the concept of optimal relevance, the strengths and weaknesses of the "macro view" of the Czech citation environment, which are then closely related to the questions of the feasibility of the proposed avenues of further research and the reflection on the follow-up research conducted by Alexandrov and Ondřejek.